Virtio TC Meeting Minutes: Feb 25, 2014

On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 03:50:10PM +0200, Michael S. Tsirkin wrote:
> VIRTIO TC Meeting, 3 December 2013

Oops, a cut and paste error.
This should read Virtio TC Meeting Minutes: Feb 25, 2014:
same as the subject.
And I copied the incorrect date into our SVN log as well :(.
> Meeting URL: https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/virtio/event.php?event_id=37115
> Notes taken by Michael S. Tsirkin
>
> 1. Opening and minuting rotation selection.
>
> minutes will be taken by: MST
>
> active attendees:
> Rusty
> MST
> Cornelia
> Pawel
> Amit
> Daniel
>
>
>
> 2. Reminder to sign in
>
>
- https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/virtio/event.php?event_id=37117
>
> Full list of attendees:
>
> Parallels IP Holdings GmbH 	James Bottomley				Member
> Mellanox Technologies, Inc. 	Haggai Eran 				Member
> Red Hat 			Stefan Hajnoczi 			Member
> IBM 				Cornelia Huck 				Member
> Oracle 				Daniel Kiper 				Member
> Oracle 				Sasha Levin 				Member
> ARM Limited 			Pawel Moll 				Member
> Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. 	Paul Mundt 				Member
> IBM 				Rusty Russell 				Chair
> Red Hat 			Amit Shah 				Member
> Red Hat 			Michael Tsirkin 			Member
> NetApp 				Bryan Venteicher 			Member
>
> 3. Review of previous minutes.
>
>
- https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/virtio/201402/msg00121.html
>
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 4. Review of subversion minor commits.
>
>
r248 PCI: minor wording change (spell out access widths)
>
r249 ccw: padding annotations
>
r250 net: fix incorrect reference.
>
r251 Gratuitous Packet Sending: clarify wording.
>
r252 SCSI: missing space.
>
r253 SCSI: fix up more fields.
>
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 5. Open issues:
> T 	Key [Descending order - Click to sort in ascending order] 	Summary 	Assignee 	Reporter 	Pr 	Status 	Res 	Created 	Updated 	Due
> 	VIRTIO-83 	ccw: Broken requirements for processing adapter interrupts 	Cornelia Huck 	Cornelia Huck 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	20/Feb/14 	24/Feb/14
>
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
>
> 	VIRTIO-82 	1. Introduction List Style 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Trivial 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	23/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
> 	VIRTIO-76 	Appendices 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	21/Feb/14
> 	VIRTIO-75 	Spelling errors, etc. 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Trivial 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	27/Jan/14 	21/Feb/14
>
> above three accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 	VIRTIO-80 	Bad sub-sectioning (23 cases) 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
>
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 	VIRTIO-79 	Hanging Paragraphs (31) 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
>
> rusty proposed to do nothing about it, and close the issue
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 	VIRTIO-77 	Conformance clause 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
>
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 	VIRTIO-71 	Conformance targets 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	23/Feb/14
>
> pawel has a slight preference for keeping legacy outside the spec, but not a strong feeling
>
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 	VIRTIO-70 	2.1 Device Status Field - Confused Language 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Trivial 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	23/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
> 	VIRTIO-69 	2.2.1 Legacy Interface: 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	23/Feb/14
> 	VIRTIO-68 	1.2 RFC2119 - Incorrect citation of valid reference 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	23/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
>
> 	VIRTIO-67 	HTML redirects - 4 	Unassigned 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
>
> above 4 accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 	VIRTIO-66 	Unnumbered Tables 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
>
> not accepted, assigned to MST
>
> 	VIRTIO-64 	2.2.1 Legacy Interface - definitions 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	23/Feb/14
> 	VIRTIO-59 	feedback: MSI-X: better document driver and device requirements 	Michael Tsirkin 	Michael Tsirkin 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	12/Feb/14 	12/Feb/14
>
> above two accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 	VIRTIO-58 	clarify meaning of LEXX tags for transitional devices 	Michael Tsirkin 	Michael Tsirkin 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	11/Feb/14 	12/Feb/14
>
> third patch:
> ">http://mid.gmane.org/[email protected]
> accepted, second MST, no objections
>
> 2nd patch
> rejected
>
> 1st patch
> ">http://mid.gmane.org/[email protected]
> rejected
>
> VIRTIO-58 deferred, rusty seconds
>
>
> 	VIRTIO-45 	Timer/Clock device 	Daniel Kiper 	Daniel Kiper 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	24/Oct/13 	20/Feb/14
> reserve ID only
> Daniel seconds
>
>
> 	VIRTIO-33 	Clearly identify feature dependencies in spec. 	Rusty Russell 	Rusty Russell 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	16/Sep/13 	24/Feb/14
>
>
> already resolved as part of 77, no need to vote on it
>
>
> New Feature 	VIRTIO-28 	Implement new balloon device (ID 13)

Rusty Russell 	Rusty Russell 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	11/Sep/13 	21/Feb/14
>
>
> Daniel seconds
>
>
> 7. Any other business.
>
> timing of the next draft:
> 	either run a ballot (takes a week)
> 	more feedback could be on the way from google
> 	will informally release a WD02 as pdf
>
> 	no changebars this time around: too many changes
> 	will start after draft 2, hopefully
>
> 	rusty's wife will have a child a month from now
> 	MST will be a co-chair and will run the meetings
> 	in his absence.
>
> 	Rusty nominates MST as co-chair, seconded by Amit
>
> MST asks how we'll manage changebars after draft 2
> 	might not be easy to do it cleanly in latex,
> 	hopefully there won't be many changes so
> 	we'll just hack around this manually
>
> 8. Confirmation of meeting schedule.
>
> 9. Adjourn
>