Virtio TC Meeting Minutes: Feb 25, 2014

VIRTIO TC Meeting, 3 December 2013  Meeting URL:  https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/virtio/event.php?event_id=37115  Notes taken by Michael S. Tsirkin  1. Opening and minuting rotation selection.  minutes will be taken by: MST  active attendees: Rusty MST Cornelia Pawel Amit Daniel
2. Reminder to sign in
-  https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/virtio/event.php?event_id=37117
Full list of attendees:  Parallels IP Holdings GmbH 	James Bottomley				Member Mellanox Technologies, Inc. 	Haggai Eran 				Member Red Hat 			Stefan Hajnoczi 			Member IBM 				Cornelia Huck 				Member Oracle 				Daniel Kiper 				Member Oracle 				Sasha Levin 				Member ARM Limited 			Pawel Moll 				Member Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. 	Paul Mundt 				Member IBM 				Rusty Russell 				Chair Red Hat 			Amit Shah 				Member Red Hat 			Michael Tsirkin 			Member NetApp 				Bryan Venteicher 			Member  3. Review of previous minutes.
-  https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/virtio/201402/msg00121.html
accepted, second MST, no objections  4. Review of subversion minor commits.
r248 PCI: minor wording change (spell out access widths)
r249 ccw: padding annotations
r250 net: fix incorrect reference.
r251 Gratuitous Packet Sending: clarify wording.
r252 SCSI: missing space.
r253 SCSI: fix up more fields.  accepted, second MST, no objections  5. Open issues: T 	Key [Descending order - Click to sort in ascending order] 	Summary 	Assignee 	Reporter 	Pr 	Status 	Res 	Created 	Updated 	Due 	VIRTIO-83 	ccw: Broken requirements for processing adapter interrupts 	Cornelia Huck 	Cornelia Huck 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	20/Feb/14 	24/Feb/14
accepted, second MST, no objections
	VIRTIO-82 	1. Introduction List Style 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Trivial 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	23/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14 	  	VIRTIO-76 	Appendices 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	21/Feb/14 	  	VIRTIO-75 	Spelling errors, etc. 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Trivial 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	27/Jan/14 	21/Feb/14
above three accepted, second MST, no objections  	VIRTIO-80 	Bad sub-sectioning (23 cases) 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
accepted, second MST, no objections  	VIRTIO-79 	Hanging Paragraphs (31) 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
rusty proposed to do nothing about it, and close the issue accepted, second MST, no objections  	VIRTIO-77 	Conformance clause 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
accepted, second MST, no objections  	VIRTIO-71 	Conformance targets 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	23/Feb/14
pawel has a slight preference for keeping legacy outside the spec, but not a strong feeling  accepted, second MST, no objections  	VIRTIO-70 	2.1 Device Status Field - Confused Language 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Trivial 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	23/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14 	  	VIRTIO-69 	2.2.1 Legacy Interface: 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	23/Feb/14 	  	VIRTIO-68 	1.2 RFC2119 - Incorrect citation of valid reference 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	23/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
	VIRTIO-67 	HTML redirects - 4 	Unassigned 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
above 4 accepted, second MST, no objections  	VIRTIO-66 	Unnumbered Tables 	Rusty Russell 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	24/Feb/14
not accepted, assigned to MST  	VIRTIO-64 	2.2.1 Legacy Interface - definitions 	Michael Tsirkin 	Patrick Durusau 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	26/Jan/14 	23/Feb/14 	  	VIRTIO-59 	feedback: MSI-X: better document driver and device requirements 	Michael Tsirkin 	Michael Tsirkin 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	12/Feb/14 	12/Feb/14
above two accepted, second MST, no objections  	VIRTIO-58 	clarify meaning of LEXX tags for transitional devices 	Michael Tsirkin 	Michael Tsirkin 	Minor 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	11/Feb/14 	12/Feb/14
third patch:  
>http://mid.gmane.org/ 
accepted, second MST, no objections  2nd patch rejected  1st patch  
>http://mid.gmane.org/ 
rejected  VIRTIO-58 deferred, rusty seconds
	VIRTIO-45 	Timer/Clock device 	Daniel Kiper 	Daniel Kiper 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	24/Oct/13 	20/Feb/14 	  reserve ID only Daniel seconds
	VIRTIO-33 	Clearly identify feature dependencies in spec. 	Rusty Russell 	Rusty Russell 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	16/Sep/13 	24/Feb/14
already resolved as part of 77, no need to vote on it
New Feature 	VIRTIO-28 	Implement new balloon device (ID 13)

Rusty Russell 	Rusty Russell 	Major 	Open Open 	UNRESOLVED 	11/Sep/13 	21/Feb/14
Daniel seconds
7. Any other business.  timing of the next draft: 	either run a ballot (takes a week) 	more feedback could be on the way from google 	will informally release a WD02 as pdf  	no changebars this time around: too many changes 	will start after draft 2, hopefully  	rusty's wife will have a child a month from now 	MST will be a co-chair and will run the meetings 	in his absence.  	Rusty nominates MST as co-chair, seconded by Amit  MST asks how we'll manage changebars after draft 2 	might not be easy to do it cleanly in latex, 	hopefully there won't be many changes so 	we'll just hack around this manually  8. Confirmation of meeting schedule.  9. Adjourn