Re: [xacml] Groups - IPC WD-06 uploaded

Hal, John,

    

    The includeInResult XML attribute should be set to "false", not
    dropped since it is required by the schema. The examples would not
    validate in a parser if you drop the these XML attributes.

    

    Best regards,

    Erik

    

    On 2011-12-14 21:53, Hal Lockhart wrote:
    
      
      
      
Another comment on the spec. In the
            example requests, all the attributes are marked with the XML
            attribute IncludeInResult="true".

      
 

      
I don't think this is appropriate
            for examples. The normal uses of this feature are A) to
            correlate responses in a multi decision request and B) to
            obtain a signed token which documents the decision.
            Obviously A does not apply and I think B suggests a
            specialized situation which would not be true for most
            parties using this Profile. I suggest dropping this
            attribute as it is likely to cause confusion.

      
 

      
Hal

      
        
-----Original Message-----

            From: John Tolbert [mailto:]

            Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2011 9:18 PM

            To: 

            Subject: [xacml] Groups - IPC WD-06 uploaded

            

          

        Submitter's message

        Revised WD-06, with anyURI data type for agreement-type and
        affiliation-type attributes. Examples updated. 

        -- Mr. John Tolbert
        
          
            

              Document
                  Name: IPC
                  WD-06

                 Description

                Working draft 6 

                Download
                  Latest Revision

                Public
                  Download Link

                 Submitter: Mr. John
                Tolbert

                Group: OASIS eXtensible Access Control
                Markup Language (XACML) TC

                Folder: Specifications and Working
                Drafts

                Date submitted: 2011-11-29 18:17:39

                Revision: 1