xacml — archive

Minutes of June 9 2004 XACML TC Meeting

From: Bill Parducci <[email protected]>
To: [email protected]
Date: Thu, 09 Jun 2005 14:48:00 -0000

MHonArc v2.5.0b2 -->

xacml message

Subject: Minutes of June 9 2004 XACML TC Meeting

From: bill parducci <[email protected]>
To: xacml <[email protected]>
Date: Thu, 09 Jun 2005 07:48:21 -0700

Anne Anderson
Seth Proctor
Bill Parducci (minutes)
Tony Nadalin
Hal Lockhart
Erik Rissanen
Ron Williams
Argyn Kuketyev
David Staggs
Michiharu Kudo
Argyn Kuketayev

Quorum NOT reached (43% per Kavi)

Agenda:

Unable to vote on minutes from 26 May meeting.

Review of Issues:

Issue:  Open request context
Owner:
Notes:  Ron requested a set of Use Cases to help clarify the issue.
Action: elaboration of Use Cases

Issue:  Issuer in policy
Owner:
Action: syntax still to be ironed out

Issue:  PDP references in policies
Owner:  FRANK
Notes:  Frank presented this at the F2F and the next step is to  examine
         potential syntax. Hal raised a concern on complexity. Seth
         concurred on potential complexity, but felt that it may be
         solvable if well bounded.
Action: elaboration needed

Issue:  Policy Statements in request context
Owner:
Action: requires a specific proposal

Issue:  Identity attributes
Owner:  FRANK
Action: requires a specfic proposal

Issue:  Maximum delagation depth
Owner:  FRANK
Action: requires a specfic proposal

Issue:  Alternate owner-policy-statement
Owner:  FRANK
Notes:  it is unclear as to what this is addressing
Action: requires more information

Issue:  Backwards compatibility
Owner:
Action: TBD based upon direction of future work

Issue:  Obligations in delagation
Owner:  MICHIHARU
Notes:  How are Obligations combined in delagation model?
Action: enumeration needed pending delagation model

Issue:  Downstream delegates
Owner:  ERIK
Action: TC review & comment - concrete proposal available

Issue:  Generalization
Owner:  TIM
Action: TC review & comment - concrete proposal available

Issue:  Permission query: permissions
Owner:
Notes:  Hal is concerned that this is an unbounded problem in large
         systems. Argyn suggested that this may be an optional behavior
         for [smaller] systems that are able to effectively query their
         environment.
Action: elaboration needed

Issue:  Permission query: action
Owner:
Notes:  How is this different from permission query?
Action: elaboration needed


meeting adjourned.