Re: [xml-dev] Getting specs/standards right (was UPA and schema handling)

From
Paul Sumner Downey <>
To
Michael Champion <>
Date
2004-10-18T19:16:51Z
ID
<>
Thread
Re: [xml-dev] Getting specs/standards right (was UPA and schema handling)
Michael Champion wrote:

> As much as I amd sure it would pain the W3C :-) maybe what's needed is
> an XML Interoperability Organization modeled on WS-I to do the
> profiling and conformance test building.

sadly under its current structure, real practical testing is not 
something the WS-I is seemingly able to undertake, let alone conformance 
testing. They have "sample applications" which, whilst interesting, only 
exhibit a small subset of possible Web service interactions. They also 
have some "testing tools" which sniff messages and compare them against 
a WSDL applying a small subset of the Basic Profile assertions.

Paul