RE: [xacml] BATCH #1: E-mail vote to close issues...

Title: BATCH #1: E-mail vote to close issues...

I vote 
to accept Batch #1.

 

Hal

 

  
-----Original Message-----
From: Carlisle Adams 
  [mailto:]
Sent: Thursday, April 04, 2002 
  4:27 PM
To: XACML TC
Subject: [xacml] BATCH #1: E-mail 
  vote to close issues...

  
Hi all, 

  
As Anne notes below, the 
  issues in this batch have been (unofficially) voted closed by the PM 
  subcommittee.  This e-mail vote is now an official opportunity to close 
  these items.  If you have any objections to the resolutions on any of 
  these issues (see resolution text in the latest Issues document), please make 
  them known to the list by responding to this e-mail.  A new resolution 
  (or an amendment to the current resolution) must be included in your 
  posting.

  
This e-mail vote closes 
  at the end of the day on Thursday, April 11, 2002.  If no objections are 
  posted by that time, the current batch of resolutions will pass and the issues 
  will be closed.

  
Carlisle. 

  
    
---------- 
From:   Anne Anderson[SMTP:] 
    
Sent:   Tuesday, April 02, 2002 11:14 AM 
    
To:     
    XACML TC 
Subject: 
           [xacml] Please verify closed issues 

    
The following issues were voted closed during a 
    Policy Model 
Subcommittee meeting on 
    March 25.  A close reading of the OASIS 
voting rules, however, persuaded us that votes should not 
    occur 
during a subcommittee meeting even 
    if a quorum is present. 

    
We will take vote at the upcoming TC meeting to 
    affirm the 
closures unless objections are 
    raised.  This is your chance to 
object to the closure or resolution of any of these issues. 
    

    
Refer to the Issues document, version 6, for 
    details of the 
issues and the resolution 
    under which they were closed. 

    
PM-1-01-A: Implementing global deny and 
    Meta-Policies 
PM-1-05: how NOT-APPLICABLE 
    impacts a combinator expression 
PM-1-07: 
    how can the set of combinators be extended? 
PM-2-01: Referencing Multiple Policies 
PM-1-01: Negative Authorizations 
PM-1-03: Post-Conditions as a term 
PM-2-03: Meaningful Actions 
PM-2-08: Outcome of policies and their combination 
PM-3-01: Combining Policy Elements 
PM-4-10: preserve PAP identity 
PM-5-11: should we use a SAML assertion as a container for an 
    
         
    XACML applicable policy. 
PM-5-17: Boolean 
    Expression of rules 
PM-8-01: Internal 
    v.s. External post conditions 
PM-8-02: 
    Mandatory v.s. advisory post conditions 
PM-8-03: Inapplicable 
PM-8-04: 
    Base policy v.s. policy reference 
PM-8-06: When to execute post condition 
PM-8-07: Extension point 
MI-1-01: 
    Consistency 
MI-1-02: Definition of Policy 
    vs. Rule 

    
Anne 
-- 
    
Anne H. 
    Anderson             
    Email:  
Sun 
    Microsystems Laboratories 
1 Network 
    Drive,UBUR02-311     Tel: 781/442-0928 
Burlington, MA 01803-0902 USA  Fax: 
    781/442-1692 

    
---------------------------------------------------------------- 
    
To subscribe or unsubscribe from this elist use 
    the subscription 
manager: 
    <http://lists.oasis-open.org/ob/adm.pl>