issue 247 - folllow up questions on static analysis table

As Vinky reported when he added the
static analysis table to the spec, there are outstanding questions that
may need further action (see

http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/wsbpel/200607/msg00000.html):

(1) SA00047 is no longer applicable
( section 10.1, description: The name of a named activity MUST be unique
among all named activities present within the same immediately enclosing
scope. ). I have removed this SA code and renumbered codes. We now have
SA 91 codes. 

(2) Cannot find description for these two codes in main body.  

      SA00053 : section 10.3.1

         For all <fromPart> elements the part
attribute MUST reference a valid message part in the WSDL message for the
operation.

     SA00054 : section 10.3.1

         For all <toPart> elements the part attribute
MUST reference a valid message part in the WSDL message for the operation.

I believe these are valid constraints but I cannot find the text in the
main body that explicitly calls this out.  Maybe someone can help
me locate the text else we can open an issue to add text. 

(3) There appears to be no SA code in the appendix for the following Static
analysis text in the main body. We can open an action item/issue to address
this: 

section 12.4.3 around line 4956 "Within a scope, the name of all named
immediately enclosed scopes MUST be unique. This requirement MUST be statically
enforced."

We will discuss these on the July 26 call.  

Regards, Diane

IBM  Emerging Internet Software Standards



(919)254-7221 or 8-444-7221, Mobile: 919-624-5123, Fax 845-491-5709