RE: [wsbpel] "Using BPEL4WS in a UDDI registry" OASIS UDDI Spec TC Technical Note - Review Requested

Thanks for your input Axel. We will consider the 
input.

 

Regards,

 

Luc Clément
Senior Program Manager, Systinet
Co-Chair OASIS UDDI Spec 
TC
Tel: +1.617.768.4268 / Cell: +1.978.793.2162 / www.systinet.com

From: Axel Martens [mailto:] 

Sent: Thursday, December 02, 2004 16:23
To: Luc 
Clement
Cc: Diane Jordan; 'James Bryce Clark'; ; 
'Mary McRae'; 'Tony Rogers'; ; 

Subject: RE: [wsbpel] "Using BPEL4WS in a 
UDDI registry" OASIS UDDI Spec TC Technical Note - Review 
Requested

Dear Luc, 

we had an internal reviewing process within IBM, and 
a 
consolidated comment should have been 
sent to the UDDI TC. 
Somehow, the 
transmission did not happen. Hence, I send you the 
comments of my group on the proposed technical note, 
attached to 
this email. As the core 
idea, we consider the explicit 
representation of the partner link concept necessary. The document 

proposes the introduction of a partner link 
tModel, the adjustment 
of the queries 
and relations, and two additional queries. The 
document describes our reasons and design decisions illustrated by 

a small example. 

Best regards, Axel. 

----------------------------------------
Axel 
Martens

Post Doc Researcher
Component Systems Group
IBM TJ Watson 
Research Center 
Hawthorne, NY (USA)
Phone: (914) 784-7480
E-mail: 
 

  
  

    "Luc Clement" 
      <> 
      
11/26/2004 08:46 AM 

    
      
        
        

          
            
To

          Diane 
            Jordan/Raleigh/IBM@IBMUS, <> 
        

          
            
cc

          <>, 
            <>, "'James Bryce Clark'" 
            <>, "'Mary McRae'" 
            <>, "'Tony Rogers'" 
            <> 
        

          
            
Subject

          RE: [wsbpel] "Using 
            BPEL4WS in a UDDI registry" OASIS UDDI Spec TC Technical Note - 
            Review Requested

      
        
        

          
          

Having provided sufficient time to review the "Using 
BPEL4WS in a UDDI Registry" Technical Note it is the UDDI Spec TC’s opinion this 
Technical Note is ready to be published. It is our intent to publish this TN by 
the end of this calendar year. That said, should you have additional feedback 
please provide it no later than 3 Dec so it may be considered prior to the 
expected ratification of the TN by this TC in mid-Dec. 
We understand that there may be unresolved 
issues relating to the relevance of abstract processes as it relates to the 
WSBPEL specification. We would like to draw your attention to the fact that the 
TN applies to the BPEL4WS 1.1 specification submitted to the WSBPEL TC and which 
defines the concept of abstract processes. The decision to map BPEL4WS 1.1 was 
deliberate – the TN aims at addressing current market needs. 
  

Luc Clément
Senior Program Manager, 
Systinet
Co-Chair OASIS UDDI Spec TC
Tel: +1.617.768.4268 / Cell: 
+1.978.793.2162 / www.systinet.com 

From: Luc Clement 
[mailto:] 
Sent: Tuesday, August 03, 2004 
20:59
To: ; 
Cc: 
; ; Karl F. Best; James 
Bryce Clark; Mary McRae; Tony Rogers
Subject: [wsbpel] "Using BPEL4WS 
in a UDDI registry" OASIS UDDI Spec TC Technical Note - Review 
Requested

Dear 
WSBPEL Chairs, 
The UDDI Spec TC has been 
working on a “Using BPEL4WS in a UDDI registry” Technical Note (TN) that it 
would like your input on before proceeding to ratify this TN. 
The TN provides a mapping for publishing BPEL4WS abstract 
processes into a UDDI registry. The primary goals of mapping BPEL4WS artifacts 
to the UDDI model are to: 
1.   
     Enable the automatic 
registration of BPEL4WS definitions in UDDI 
2.        Enable optimized and flexible UDDI queries based on specific BPEL4WS 
artifacts and metadata 
3.        Provide 
composability with the mapping described in the "Using WSDL in a UDDI 
Registry, Version 2.0.2" [1] Technical Note. 
We would like to invite the BPEL TC to review and comment on the document 
and ask that you assign two or more reviewers. 
The TN is posted at the following locations by format: 

  
PDF: http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/uddi-spec/download.php/8442/uddi-spec-tc-tn-bpel-20040725.pdf 
  
MSWord: http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/uddi-spec/download.php/8441/uddi-spec-tc-tn-bpel-20040725.doc 
We would 
appreciate comments as soon as possible but preferably before 31 Aug 04. Please 
submit comments: 
To: Claus von Riegen, SAP 
(), 

cc: (UDDI Chairs): ; 
 
cc: 
 
Thanks in advance 

Luc Clément           
              
Co-Chair OASIS UDDI Spec TC 
Systinet Corporation
Tel: 
+1.617.395.6798 
  
  
[1] OASIS UDDI Spec TC 
Technical Note: “Using WSDL in a UDDI Registry, Version 2.0.2”, http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/uddi-spec/doc/tns.htm#WSDLTNV2