RE: [wsbpel] Issue - 88 - Import Errata

From
Ugo Corda <>
Date
2003-12-04T00:02:15+00:00
ID
Thread
RE: [wsbpel] Issue - 88 - Import Errata
> 
What happens if an engine chooses not to honor the import?
> The current text of the BPEL spec states 
that the BPEL engine 

> is 
not required to import the files it is pointed at. 
 

 I don't 
think that not importing the files necessarily implies that the import is not 
honored.

 

The original 
statement in the resolution of Issue 7 was:

 

"A 
<bpel:import> location element will be interpreted as a hint for BPEL 
processors. In particular, processors are not required to retrieve the imported 
document from the specified location".

 

So it only says that 
the location information is a hint (but the import statement could 
still be satisfied by other means).

 

The statement 
appearing in the latest draft is more ambiguous:

 

"The presence of an 
<import> element should be interpreted as a hint to the BPEL4WS processor. 
In particular, processors are not required to retrieve the imported document 
from the location specified on the <import> element".

 

Now it is saying 
that the <import> element itself is a hint. Not sure what exactly that 
means.

 

Ugo