Re: [office] OpenDocument TC Coordination Call Minutes 2006-07-10

I don't know if we will state that
the embedded spreadsheet is an interim solution in ODF 1.1, but I do think
it's better to let the users know that we will work on this in ODF 1.2.
I add my thought of the statement like this <my>...</my>.

--------------E3
Tables in Presentations----------------------

Users importing non-OpenDocument
slides that contain tables need access to the table structure via their
assistive technology. Therefore tables imported into OpenDocument from
another file format must have their structure preserved, and <my>because
there is no in-line table specification, the interim solution is such table</my>should
be imported as embedded spreadsheets. <my>Because of the character
difference between spreadsheet and in-line table, some information of non-OpenDoucment
in slide table information could not be interpreted into embedded SpreadSheet
 To maintain the information interoperability, foreign element or
attribute could be introduced to identify those characters that not contained
in embedded spreadsheet, such as table dimension and the creation method
of embedded SpreadSheet which could be used to differentiate the embedded
spreadsheet created by importing from non-OpenDocument or by adding as
an native Object.</my>

Ma Yue

Lars Oppermann <>

Sent by: 

07/11/2006 05:47 AM

To



cc

Subject

[office] OpenDocument TC Coordination
Call Minutes 2006-07-10

1. Dial-In, Roll Call

Helen Yue, IBM

Yue Ma, IBM

Patrick Durusau, Individual

Robert Weir, IBM

Waldo Bastian, Intel

David Faure, KDE

Lars Oppermann, Sun Microsystems

Bruce D'Arcus, The OpenDocument Foundation

Gary Edwards, The OpenDocument Foundation

David Wheeler, The OpenDocument Foundation

Florian Reuter, The OpenDocument Foundation

2. Approval of Meeting Minutes, Action Item Review

Last Minutes:

The attending TC members unanimously accepted the minutes from the last

coordination call.

Action Items:

DavidW, Eike: prepare apostrophe proposal

-> Eikes mail already includes enough information to put this into the
spec.

ACTION: Lars to add the syntax to the spec

Yue Ma: post examples for potential table-embedding problems

-> done

Lars: edit proposals into 1.1 draft

-> done

3. OpenDocument 1.0 2nd Edition

Public review has ended. There were no comments received, that concern

the specification directly. The comments received during the review

phase where:

1. http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/office-comment/200606/msg00013.html

2.

http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/office-comment/200606/msg00000.html

Comment 1 concerned handling of table-cell-properties and was describing

a behavior experienced in a specific implementation of the specification.

Comment 2 concerned inconsistent capitalization of style names. Style

names however are not part of the OpenDocument specification. Hence the

comment addresses an issue with a specific implementation of the

OpenDocument format

RESOLUTION: the comments have no impact on OpenDocument 1.0 2nd Edition.

The TC can start the vote for committee specification

ACTION: Lars to request committee-spec ballot

RESOLUTION:

The responses to ISO comments at

http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/download.php/18912/iso-comment-responses.odt

are the final and approved version of the TCs responses.

4. OpenDocument 1.1

Degrees vs. radiants.

In general, it should be clarified in the spec, that angle measurements

are in units of degrees for draw-elements and -attributes.

Tables in presentations

Embedded spreadsheets are an interims solution, until a full solution is

included into ODF 1.2. There are some issues with the flexibility of

embedded tables vs. inline tables. But we don't want to inflate the

interims solution unnecessarily.

(YueMa:) I will post a proposal for a statement on this to the list

(David:) is the show-end-of-presentation-slide included in the current

draft?

ACTION: Lars: make sure end of proposal is included for end of

presenation-slide (from DavidF), default is true

New Action Items:

ACTION: Lars to add the apostrophe to the spec for cell names

ACTION: Lars to request committee-spec ballot

ACTION: Lars: make sure end of proposal is included for end of

presenation-slide (from DavidF), default is true

Next Conference Call

coordination call: 2006-07-17, 3:00PM-4:00PM UTC

-- 

Lars Oppermann <>        
      Sun Microsystems

Software Engineer - StarOffice            
              Sachsenfeld 4

Phone: +49 40 23646 959              
                 D-20097 Hamburg

Fax:   +49 40 23646 550            
     http://www.sun.com/staroffice

---------------------------------------------------------------------

To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that

generates this mail.  You may a link to this group and all your TCs
in OASIS

at:

https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php