Re: [ocpp] Groups - Request for Change - OCPP Security uploaded

Dear Robert, 

thanks for submitting this Security RFC for OCPP. I have taken the time to read through the complete document. From my point of view this is a nicely defined document and a good piece of work.

However, there are some aspects which I would like to be addressed, some of them coming from the ISO 15118 domain. I posted my comments in the file attached to this email. They are marked as yellow comments, hope you all can read them. 

I am not sure about the normal process as I am a new individual member, but I think the way such a commenting works is not by uploading another revision here (https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/ocpp/document.php?document_id=59309) by myself, right? 

Looking forward to the discussion later.

Best,

Dr.-Ing. Marc Mültin

V2G Clarity

Mobil:  +49 170 8668645



Expertenwissen und Blog zur E-Mobilität sowie dem Vehicle-2-Grid Kommunikationsstandard ISO 15118 unter:

http://www.v2g-clarity.com

Attachment:
161101 Security Specification OCPP (v0.9)_comments_MarcMültin.pdf

Description: Adobe PDF document

Am 08.11.2016 um 21:30 schrieb Robert de Leeuw <>:

        Submitter's message
        I have received an updated version of the Security RFC.
If you are participating in the Security call on Wednesday and haven't read the Security proposal, please take some to to browse through it.

Kind regards

Robert de Leeuw (IHomer)
        
-- Mr. Robert de Leeuw
        
    

    
        Document Name: Request for Change - OCPP Security
        
        Description
        This document describes a security specification for the OCPP protocol. The
OCPP protocol is used to connect Electric Vehicle Charge Points to the
Central System. The security specification was prepared by ENCS on request
of ElaadNL to support the further development and standardization of OCPP.
It is based amongst others on the end-to-end security design prepared for
Elaad by LaQuSo [22].        
        Download Latest Revision
        Public Download Link        
        Submitter: Mr. Robert de Leeuw
                Group: OASIS OCPP Electric Vehicle Charging Equipment Data Exchange TC
        Folder: Contributions
        Date submitted: 2016-11-08 04:29:59
                Revision: 1